Fwd: Re: [Indo-Eurasia] **The Farmer-Sproat-Witzel Model

[Asko Parpola]

I forgot to mention that my paper was published in:
Transactions of the International Conference of Eastern Studies, No. 50 
(2005): 28-66, Tokyo: The Toho Gakkai (The Institute of Eastern Culture), 
December 2005.  This is not mentioned in the PDF, which reproduces pp. 28-66 
of the publication.

----- Forwarded message from Asko Parpola <asko.parpola at helsinki.fi> -----
    Date: Sat, 10 Feb 2007 19:20:27 +0200
    From: Asko Parpola <asko.parpola at helsinki.fi>
Reply-To: Asko Parpola <asko.parpola at helsinki.fi>
 Subject: Re: [Indo-Eurasia] **The Farmer-Sproat-Witzel Model
      To: Indology <INDOLOGY at liverpool.ac.uk>

Quoting Michael Witzel <witzel at FAS.HARVARD.EDU>:

>Incidentally,  if some things were said about the F-S-W paper at 
Madison in October 2005(?), this has not reached my ears yet. The only  
thing in writing  so far is a rather polemic paper by my friend  A. 
Parpola, his talk at Tokyo in June 2005, where I was present. There was 
NO time for discussion! We did that a few weeks later, in his, M. 
Kenoyer's, Steve's and my  presence, at Kyoto.  A good defense for the 
"script" model did not emerge. Kenoyer conceded that the Indus signs do 
not represent written language (like sentences)  but he still called 
them a 'script' ...

**********************

A PDF file of my paper is available at the following internet address:
http://www.helsinki.fi/~aparpola/tices_50.pdf 

In the paper I analyze all the arguments of the Farmer-Sproat-Witzel paper 
and find them inconclusive. To what extent I succeeded in defending the 
"script" model and to what extent the paper is polemic is of course not for 
me but for the readers to judge.

With best regards, 

Asko Parpola
Institute for Asian and African Studies
POB 59 (Unioninkatu 38 B)
FIN-00014 University of Helsinki, Finland
----- End forwarded message -----


Asko Parpola
Institute for Asian and African Studies
POB 59 (Unioninkatu 38 B)
FIN-00014 University of Helsinki, Finland