Horse, unicorn, etc.
Arun Gupta
suvidya at WORLDNET.ATT.NET
Sun Jul 23 12:21:16 UTC 2000
1. Why do we use the word "unicorn" to describe the creature depicted on
so many Harappan seals ? The classical unicorn is said to have the
body of a horse; and the Harappan ones do not.
2. What is the Harappan creature ? Is it merely a bull in profile,
thereby showing only a single horn ? Or is it a creature with some
mythical significance ?
3. Why does Wendy O'Flaherty in her translation of RV 1.116 mention that
"the donkey is sometimes said to pull the Asvins' chariot" and
"the she-wolf for whome Rajrasva slaughtered the rams is said to
have been one of the donkeys of the Asvins in disguise" ?
Is "Asvin" a word the translator inserted there ? Would not Asvins
have horses, not donkeys ? Or does the word "Asvin" predate the
association of asva with horse ?
4. Could Indo-Aryans have translated the Harappan cult of the "unicorn"
into the cult of the horse ? Do we know of horse sacrifices from
contemporary IE speakers ?
5. Paul Manansala wrote some time ago :
Equus sivalensis may be gone but domesticated horses with sivalensis
dentition, pre-orbital depression and 17 pairs of ribs are still found
in South and Southeast Asia.
O'Flaherty in translation of RV 1.162 has the axe cutting through the
thirty four ribs -- any significance here ? Or are the extra pair of
ribs in equus caballus not really noticeable in any such axe cut ?
Sorry, but a fool can ask more questions than a wise man can answer.
-arun gupta
More information about the INDOLOGY
mailing list