Panjabi grammar, accent, comparative analysis

B. Reusch reusch at
Tue Jul 8 14:57:33 UTC 1997

At 11:47 +0100 7/8/97, Adrian Burton wrote:
>As far as I recall they [tones] have not been connected to the Vedic
>accents but are
>said to have developped relatively recently as a result of  phonemic
>(tonemic) change.

You are right. They compensate for the loss of voice-aspiration and plain
aspiration. I was asking for more general and historical analyses, assuming
that I must be missing something.
Also, I recall having heard that Panjabi is the only modern Indo-Aryan
language that may have derived from Vedic rather than from Classical Skt.
and would like to have specific sources on that.
Thank you.

Beatrice Reusch
University of California, Berkeley

More information about the INDOLOGY mailing list