Dear friends, 

Perhaps I'm missing something, but prof. Slaje's argument would work only with the assumption that the verse/text was mediated through Śāradā only and no other script until the printed form. I am completely unfamiliar with the manuscript history of this text. Moreover, I am looking at an 11th c. Śāradā ms. right now (do we have anything slightly earlier?): while ccha and stha are clearly different, they are not _that_ different and I can see how in a hurried hand they could've been confused.

As for sgrib byed/med, a Tibetan could have thought that such an inauspicious word is not apposite for a maṅgala/pratijñā verse, but perhaps it is nothing more than a psychological slip: while sgrib byed and sgrib med occur more or less at the same rate (quick grep through the Bstan 'gyur yields 68 vs 67), a search for sgrib pa med pa vs sgrib pa byed pa yields 919 to 1.

Best wishes, 
Peter


On Tue, Oct 15, 2019 at 12:09 PM Roland Steiner via INDOLOGY <indology@list.indology.info> wrote:
Let me add a comment right now.

That śrīmacchakuna° cannot be corrupted from śrīmatthakkana° is of 
course completely correct. My original consideration was that śakuna 
could have been a reading in a direct or indirect source of the verse 
(which is not to be emended text-critically then), but I had lost the 
focus on this in the further discussion.

Walter's idea that the author could have replaced the negatively 
connoted sthagana with a positively connoted śakuna, is very worth 
considering. Something similar could have happened in the course of 
the transmission of the Tibetan translation. It is conceivable that 
sgrib byed was held to be inappropriate for a name (and therefore to 
be a potential textual corruption) and was replaced by sgrib med 
(perhaps in the sense of anāvaraṇa "free from destruction", or similar).

Best,
Roland


_______________________________________________
INDOLOGY mailing list
INDOLOGY@list.indology.info
indology-owner@list.indology.info (messages to the list's managing committee)
http://listinfo.indology.info (where you can change your list options or unsubscribe)