On 26-04-2016 21:53, Rafal Kleczek wrote:
The īśvāra-praṇidhāna of the PYŚ, for example, often takes on a more sectarian flavor in the later texts, such as śaṅkara-pūjanaṃ in the Śivayogadīpikā 

Sankarapuujanam need be taken to be 'a sectarian flavour'. For, Isvara denotes only Siva as we find in all the Upanishads and other texts; Svetasvataropanishad repeats this word many times and it can not be interpreted in other ways.

As Kalidasa says in the invocatory verse of his drama, Vikramorvasiyam,

    vedānteu yamāhurekapurua vyāpya sthita rodasī /

    yasminnīśvara ityananyaviaya śabdo yathārthākara /


Isvara denotes only Siva from the early period. Kalidasa is of the firm view that the entire Vedanta corpus (vedānteu) proclaims Siva to be the highest Reality (purua) that pervades all the universe Kalidasa and Patanjali definitely belong to very early period. Thus by īśvāra-praṇidhāna it is fully plausible and also possible,  that Patanjali meant only worship of Siva. And, worshipping a supreme God need not be interpreted as ''sectarian''. One cannot ''worship'' a supreme reality which is nirguna.



Ganesan

--