[INDOLOGY] Another round in the California textbook story

Tue May 3 00:50:11 UTC 2016

Thank you, Dominik, for the article, and Ram-prasad, for the insightful comments.

The term “right-wing” seems inappropriate since it super-imposes yet another layer of Christian designations onto a different set of issues for the Hindu diaspora and next gen struggling to make sense of their history and find agency in its articulation.

There are two things alarming to me:

(1) Issues of caste are often brought immediately to the front in Hindu chapters, as if that’s the core of Hinduism. One could argue there are more interesting and central issues children could learn, and, as noted by others, the racism, bigotry, etc. in Abrahamic history is often not highlighted in adjacent chapters. Why?

(2) Much controversy could be erased if publishers allowed well established academics in RS, Indology, etc., who are Hindu, write the chapters. My understanding is that the publishers won't pass their agency over to Hindu scholars, even those with distinguished careers in academia.

Sincerely,
Jonathan Edelmann

Jonathan Edelmann <https://florida.academia.edu/JonathanEdelmann>
Assistant Professor
University of Florida
Department of Religion

> On Apr 15, 2016, at 12:34 PM, Ram-Prasad, Chakravarthi <c.ram-prasad at lancaster.ac.uk> wrote:
> 
> As someone who watched my son's essay when he was at school actually get marked down in History because he argued that it did not make sense to talk about what was ‘good’ about the British Empire, I do get fed up about the huge variations in what counts as enough ‘realism’ for school children, and how nationalism (and its asociated religious history) regularly whitewashes the past. Looking at undergraduates in Britain, a great deal more of unvarnished reality is needed. 
> In Britain, it is notable that Christianity gets read in school under ‘Theology’ and ‘Ethics’, so that the focus is almost entirely on conceptual issues, while Hinduism is mostly studied sociologically. So students coming into first year university classes are all prepped up about the evils of caste and the maltreatment of women in Hinduism, with nary a thought about the iniquities perpetrated in the name of Christianity across history. From the little I have seen of Californian school books, this seems to be so there as well.
> I have no doubt that it is plain immoral that, under the guise of protecting children, the HAF and others want to write out the Hindu history and contemporary reality of discrimination. 
> But I do wonder why this story does not engage with the legitimate question of disparity that has been vitiated by denialism. Are sixth-graders getting a taste of the egregious evils visited upon American society by Christian activists today? About the unbelievable suffering brought about by anti-abortion fundamentalism? About Spanish inquisitions and brutal missionaries, about the theology of imperialism, the Pauline subordination of women that has been such a model for modernity’s gender discrimination, etc., etc.?
> 
> Ram
> 
> Professor Chakravarthi Ram-Prasad
> Lancaster UniversityFrom: INDOLOGY [indology-bounces at list.indology.info <mailto:indology-bounces at list.indology.info>] on behalf of Dominik Wujastyk [wujastyk at gmail.com <mailto:wujastyk at gmail.com>]
> Sent: Friday, April 15, 2016 5:09 PM
> To: Indology
> Subject: [INDOLOGY] Another round in the California textbook story
> 
> 
> ---- 
> Hindutva Efforts to Rewrite History in California Schools Fail <http://thewire.in/2016/04/15/hindutva-efforts-to-rewrite-history-in-california-schools-fail-29751/>
> // The Wire <http://thewire.in/2016/04/15/hindutva-efforts-to-rewrite-history-in-california-schools-fail-29751/>
> Right-wing Hindu groups are seeking to gloss over Indian history and deny the reality of caste discrimination by deleting the word ‘Dalit’ from the history textbooks in California.
> 
> Right-wing groups are trying to deny the reality of caste discrimination. Credit: Wikimedia Commons
> 
> New York: California reviews its textbooks every six years, inviting public opinion each time. The process has never been easy. The ‘golden state’ has again got far more than it bargained for in its latest round of reviews, with American right-wing Hindu groups demanding changes to the history and social science textbooks used in the sixth and seventh grades.
> 
> On March 28, the Hindu American Foundation (HAF), the Uberoi Foundation for Religious Studies and the Dharma Civilization Foundation suffered a setback when a history and social science committee in Sacramento threw out most of the changes they wanted to make to the new California textbooks, which are slated for publication later this year. However, the California State Board of Education is scheduled to vote on the proposed framework changes in May.
> 
> “As much as it is about California textbooks, it is truly a battle which is ideological in nature,” said Thenmozhi Soundararajan of the Ambedkar Association of California, which with six other secular Indian groups is trying to make sure the “egregious edits” submitted by HAF to the education board don’t find their way into the textbooks.
> 
> According to activists like Soundararajan, right-wing Hindu groups want to gloss over Indian history and deny the reality of caste discrimination by deleting the word ‘Dalit’ from the history textbooks of the state.
> 
> “You can’t distort facts, whitewash history and deny what’s happened to millions of Indians from marginalised communities who are victims of caste apartheid,” said Soundararajan, who is the co-founder of Dalit History Month. “You cannot tamper with and bring ideology into the framing of the past.”
> 
> HAF and other right-wing Hindu groups, however, maintain that issues such as the caste system, the plight of dalits and discrimination against women do not belong in a sixth-grade introduction to world civilisations. HAF says that Indian American children are embarrassed by the depiction of Hinduism in ancient India in the history textbook.
> 
> California ninth grader Akanksha Maddi wrote in a statement released by HAF that the textbooks are unfair to students of Indian heritage.
> 
> “My classmates and teachers think that we Hindus still believe in primitive and unjust practices,” Maddi wrote. “I don’t want my friends to look down upon me and my culture because of my textbook.”
> 
> The Uberoi Foundation for Religious Studies says Hindus are merely seeking parity with other religions in sixth grade textbooks, where social problems of other religions are not given the same prominence, even as the redeeming features of Hinduism are ignored.
> 
> Shiva G. Bajpai, professor emeritus of Asian Studies at California State University, asked the education board for a revision, writing: “Hindu children are bullied by their classmates for the system of varna and jatibecause the social iniquities of other religions go unmentioned… If the commission insists on keeping lines 862 to 874, it should add 300 to 400 word comments on social order and slavery for the Abrahamic religions.”
> 
> A poster protesting the Hindu American Foundation’s claims, also showing an image from an American history textbook explaining the caste system.
> 
> However, the South Asian Faculty Group made up of South Asian scholars from Stanford, UC Berkeley, San Francisco State University and UCLA, among others, held that history should not be tampered with, even if it is unpleasant.
> 
> “We are disturbed by claims that an equitable portrayal should prevail over historical accuracy,” said an expert who didn’t want to be named for fear of being targeted. “It is a slippery slope.”
> 
> Protests over “erasing” India 
> 
> HAF is spearheading protests across America because it says it has discovered over 30 places in the sixth and seventh grade history textbooks where the words “Hindu” or “India” would be replaced in the new textbooks with “South Asia.”
> 
> Samir Kalra, senior director of HAF, told  <https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/education/wp/2016/04/12/hindu-group-protests-possible-california-textbook-changes/>The Washington Post <https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/education/wp/2016/04/12/hindu-group-protests-possible-california-textbook-changes/> that the proposed changes could have “implications for several years forward,” and could diminish the significance of Hindus in the ancient civilisation of India. Kalra told the newspaper that the textbook changes appear to only reflect revisions aimed at India and Hinduism: China will not be changed to “East Asia,” nor will there be changes to any references to Islam, Christianity, Judaism, Sikhism or any other religions.
> 
> The South Asian Faculty Group has fired back, saying that during the submissions in the public comment process it suggested that in some places “India” be replaced with “South Asia” because some of the areas discussed currently belong to Pakistan and are not aligned with modern-day India.
> 
> “Although ‘Ancient India’ is common in the source material, when discussing the Indus Valley Civilisation, we believe it will cause less confusion to students to refer to the “Early Civilisation of South Asia” or “Ancient South Asia” because much of the Indus Valley is now in modern Pakistan. Conflating “Ancient India” with the modern nation-state of India deprives students from learning about the shared civilisational heritage of India and Pakistan,” the group said in a letter responding to HAF.
> 
> The California State Board of Education will vote in May on whether to retain descriptions of the caste system, role of women, Aryan migrational history and polytheism in ancient Hindu religion and other issues – as the textbook furore rages on.
> 
> ---- 
> 
> Shared via my feedly reader <http://feedly.com/>
> --
> Sent from Dominik Wujastyk's Android phone
> 
> _______________________________________________
> INDOLOGY mailing list
> INDOLOGY at list.indology.info <mailto:INDOLOGY at list.indology.info>
> indology-owner at list.indology.info <mailto:indology-owner at list.indology.info> (messages to the list's managing committee)
> http://listinfo.indology.info <http://listinfo.indology.info/> (where you can change your list options or unsubscribe)

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://list.indology.info/pipermail/indology/attachments/20160502/58dfc52e/attachment.htm>