Rajayoga
Dermot Killingley
dermot at GREVATT.FORCE9.CO.UK
Thu May 3 09:55:31 UTC 2012
Can anyone help me with the history of the term rAjayoga?
De Michelis (History of Modern Yoga p. 178), and D. G. White (Yoga in Practice p.
20) say that in modern yoga movements it's identified with Patanjali, and that this
started with Blavatsky. Theosophical writers also oppose rAja-yoga (spiritual and
superior) to haTha-yoga (physical and inferior) (e.g. Sinnett Esoteric Buddhism p.
27). This usage, especially the identification with Patanjali, is followed by
Vivekananda, who owed more to Theosophy than he liked to admit.
Going further back, the haTha-yoga-pradIpikA (HYP 2.76) says rAja-yoga and
HaTha-yoga should be practised together, but also lists rAja-yoga as one of the terms
for the highest state (HYP 4.3-4).
White (Yoga in Practice p. 17) says that according to HYP haTha-yoga leads to jIvan-
mukti and rAja-yoga leads to videha-mukti, but I don't find this in the text.
Further back again, the yoga-tattva-upanishad lists mantra-yoga, laya-yoga, haTha-
yoga and rAja-yoga (Dasgupta Hist Ind Phil vol 1 p. 229; Eliade Yoga p. 129).
And has the term rAja-yoga anything to do with the mahIpAla-vidhi (MBh 12.308.25)
which Edgerton observes "agrees perfectly with the Gita's usual definition of yoga"
("The meaning of sAMkhya and yoga" (American Journal of Philology vol. 45) p. 45)?
Can anyone fill any of the many gaps in this story? For instance, granted that
Blavatsky popularised the identification of rAja-yoga with Patanjali, she can't have just
invented it, so where did she get it from?
Dermot Killingley
More information about the INDOLOGY
mailing list