taxonomy question

Artur Karp karp at UW.EDU.PL
Tue Aug 16 10:51:31 UTC 2011


>> Girnar Rock Edict II: PaMthesU kUpA ca khAnApita, vrachA ca ropApitA paribhogAya pasu-manusAnaM.



>> E. Hultzsch (1925, p. 4): "On the roads wells were caused to be dug , and trees were caused to be planted for the use of cattle and men."



>> Jules Bloch (1950, p. 95) reverses the order, for him men must go first : "[...] à l'usage des hommes et des bêtes".


> Is the order of the compound in the original based on any sort of priority, or merely on style, the presumption that in a dvandva longer words should come after shorter?


Dear Allen,

I do not feel competent enough to reasonably comment
on your comment re word order in dvandva compounds. But would gladly
learn from the panditas on the List.

Artur





More information about the INDOLOGY mailing list