Age of the Veda ...
naga_ganesan at HOTMAIL.COM
Tue Nov 30 20:43:45 UTC 1999
>Apparently, there is a need for precision here: I did not say that
>the Rig as we know goes back to the year 4.500 BCE. [...]
>consequently go back to the period when the Indo-Europeans were together -
>wherever and whenever that was. The point of
>break-up is often said to be about 4,500 BCE. It is a rough figure, and I
>am not dogmatic about it.
David Anthony, 1996, Shards of Speech(Proto-Indo-European language),
The Sciences, v. 36, p. 34-40:
"Terms for wheel, axle and draft pole, and a verb meaning 'to go or
convey in a vehicle' suggest that PIE existed as a single language
after 3500 B.C., when wheeled vehicles were invented. PIE must have
begun to disintegrate before 2000 B.C.: by 1500 B.C. three of its
daughter languages - Greek, Hittie and Indic - had become quite
dissimilar. Altogether, then the linguistic evidence points to a
homeland between the Ural and Caucasus mountains, in the centuries
between 3500 and 2000 B.C."
2000 BCE is the date of invention for Chariots.
A 3000 BCE date (possibly later) for PIE
breakup seems reasonable. It appears 4500 BCE is an overestimate,
note the lower limit in Anthony is as late as 2000 BCE.
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com
More information about the INDOLOGY