Tanagalai and Vadagalai
Balaji Hebbar
bhebbar at EROLS.COM
Sun May 9 14:08:32 UTC 1999
Mr. Satyanarayana:
It is first of all "Tengalai" (Tamil for DakShiNakala) not
"Tanagalai". The "AShTAdashabhedanirNaya" is a Sanskrit work that
deals quite extensively about the 18 principal differences in
doctrine between the Tengalai and the VaDagalai branches of the
Shri-VaishNava SampradAya. It has been published by the French
Indological Institute at Pondicherry. Also, Prof. Patricia Mumme
(PhD. Univ. of Pennsylvania) did her dissertation on this whole
issue. I think her work is entitled "Shri-VaishNava Theological
dispute". It has also been published in India. Really speaking,
these 18 can reduced to some 4 super important ones. They
are:
1. T: God's Grace is Sovereign. It cannot be "bought" by good
works.
V: Good works invoke the Grace of God.
2. T: Prapatti is mandatory as a means to mokSha.
V: Prapatti is an optional means to mokSha.
3. T: ShrI does not share in the Divine Essence.
V: ShrI is inseparable from God and shares the Divine
Essence. (a la Tengalai this is Duotheism not Monotheism)
4. T: Salvific powers belong to God only.
V: ShrI shares in the salvific powers of God.
Regards,
B.N.Hebbar
Adjunct Professor of Eastern Religions
George Washington University (Washington DC USA)
Lecturer of Indology
University of Maryland Honors Program
PaNDitaratna, ShAstrasavyaSAchI, VedAntavyAghra
More information about the INDOLOGY
mailing list