The Aryans (again); 19th century discourse.

[Kambhampaty, Krishna]

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Lars Martin Fosse [mailto:lmfosse at ONLINE.NO]
> Sent: Monday, January 04, 1999 11:57
>
> Perhaps we should add, for the benefit of Ashish, that practically the
whole
> discussion can be found in the Indology archives. There he will find all
the
> arguments that can possibly be brought to bear on the subject rehashed
several
> times.  He will also find references to various books on the subjects. I
agree
> that we now should regard the AIT/AMT as a closed subject.
>
> There is little more to be said, except perhaps to exchange bibliographic
notes.
>
> Best regards,
>
> Lars Martin Fosse
>

I wonder if Dr. Fosse, or anyone else well-acquainted with this subject,
would summarize for new list entrants, like myself, as to how this topic
achieved closure. In selectively reading the archives it appears to me that
more facts are needed for closure since both competing theories have
deficiencies.

Barring any new findings, this topic could be treated as a dormant subject
but definitely not a closed one. Any thoughts? BTW, I am not a scholar but
would like to be one.

Regards,

Krishna Kambhampaty