typing Sanskrit an other Indian languages
tantrapl at hektor.umcs.lublin.pl
tantrapl at hektor.umcs.lublin.pl
Sun Sep 8 10:12:08 UTC 1996
In answer to Anshuman Pandeys questions:
> > II) What features should such a system of transcription possess?
> > I think it should:
> >
> > 2) It should not go against internationally accepted conventions of using
> > Roman script (like usage of capital letters). Let us not get mistaken by
> > names like INTRANS which are rather expression of aspiration (and tool of
> > promotion) than real respect for international conventions.
>
> What is meant by the second part about not "gettiog mistaken by names like
> INTRANS..."? Secondly, what is INTRANS? And why is it an expression of
> aspiration rather than an expression of respect for international
> conventions? And thirdly, what does respect for international conventions
> have to do with this matter? (Do international conventions actually
> exist?)
Maybe, I used words which sound to sharp. Sorry, if I
offended anybody. The name INTRANS suggests to me International
Transcription and I think many net surfers while getting to a site
presenting this scheme of transcription of Sanskrit into Roman script will
get an impression the scheme is internationally accepted one.
While I think it is all right to have international or universal aspirations
I would rather avoid the names suggesting international acceptance of a
project. The international convention I meant was the international scientific system
transcription of Sanskrit (with diacritical marks above or below letters
which I was trying to render with upper or lower strokes (respectively)
after a respective letter. "Respect" can be undestood in pragmatic terms.
The international scientific transcription is going to stay with us for some
time. This is why I think some similarity of a transcription scheme meant
for typing Sanskrit (and other Indian languages) to the scientific
transcription makes the whole set of procedures more coherent.
Thank you,
Leslaw Borowski
More information about the INDOLOGY
mailing list