Tamil and Sanskrit
s. kalyanaraman
s._kalyanaraman at mail.asiandevbank.org
Mon Feb 20 08:07:22 UTC 1995
In one of his postings, Mr. Kichenassamy asserted that "there is no
contestation of the fact that Tamil and Sanskrit are unrelated (see
Burrow and Emeneau's dictionary)". Now there is a contestation. I have
demonstrated that about 4,000 of the so-called 5,000 Dravidian etyma
in the Burrow and Emeneau's dictionary have no reason to exist
independendently of their so-called Aryan counter-part etyma. In fact,
they coalesce into the 12,500 etyma of the so-called Indo-Aryan and
Santali/Mundarica/Sora languages. My theses are simple: (1) South Asia
was a linguistic area which had a lingua franca, bhaaSaa circa 2500 BC
(the date of the Indus-Sarasvati civilization), from which the
so-called aryan-dravidian-munda streams emanated; (2) semantic
structures are deeper than the surface grammatical structures in
neural networks used for language evolution and expansion.
Re: South Asian languages (25+): a multi-language, etymological dictionary on CD-ROM;
Author: Dr. S. Kalyanaraman (After 1 March 1995:) 20/7 Warren Road, Mylapore, Madras 600004; Tel. 91-44-493-6288; Fax. 91-44-499-6380
The monumental work is 2,500 pages in fine print. It has 8,000 head semantic-clusters which encompass over 1.5 million words. [Thus over 4000 headword of Burrow and Emeneau's
Dravidian etyma coalesce into over 12,000 headwords of Turner's Indo-Aryan etyma
and hundreds of Santali/Mundari/Sora lexemes to generate a semantic
super-set of Vaak or Sarasvati or Braahmi which may be appropriate
appellations for the ancient South Asian lingua franca.]
The work was prepared on WordPerfect 5.1 and occupied 25MB of disk space.
I do not know the publisher's price for the CD-ROM. This work which marks a change of
paradigm in South Asian language studies, will be of interest to the indology group;
for further details on the multi-media multi-language comparative dictionary of south asian languages, contact: Scanrom Publications, 401 Church Avenue, Cedarhurst, N.Y. 11516; Tel.
516-295-2237; 1-800-269-2237; Fax. 516-295-2240; 73760,1005 Compuserve
More information about the INDOLOGY
mailing list