pratiika/allegory

Harsha Dehejia harshadehejia at HOTMAIL.COM
Tue May 1 11:54:24 EDT 2007


Friends:
 
It is useful to bring in the concept of mukhyartha bAdhA or breakdown of primary meaning.
 
In a lakshanA or simple metaphor there is mukyartha bAdhA while in dhvani or extended metaphor or allegory there is no mukyartha bAdhA.
 
Regards.
 
Harsha
Harsha V. Dehejia
Carleton University, Ottawa, ON., Canada.



> Date: Tue, 1 May 2007 17:06:57 +0200> From: christophe.vielle at UCLOUVAIN.BE> Subject: Re: pratiika/allegory> To: INDOLOGY at liverpool.ac.uk> > At the end of his commentary on Maalatiimaadhava > entitled the Rasamañjarii (Trivandrum Sanskrit > Series 170, p. 621), Puur.nasarasvatii (ca 1300) > gives an allegorical meaning for each of the > characters of Bhavabuuti's play, without really > theorizing on his views. But according to his > stress on the concept of deeper or implicit > meaning in his Vidyullataa's commentary on the > Meghasa.mde/sa (cf. Poul Skraep, Orientalia > Suecana, 27-28, 1978-79, pp. 176-210), I suggest, > without being a specialist,that his ideas on > «allegory» (without naming it as such) belong to > the sphere of the theory of suggestion (dhvani).> Best wishes,> Christophe Vielle> > > > > > > > >Dear Matthew,> >> >While I don't have any suggestion for the earliest use of> >pratiika as a possible calque for allegory, I do know (from> >a conversation with Aditya Behl a year or so ago) that the> >term is used more widely in Hindi literary criticism to> >describe, for instance, the similarly 'allegorical'> >dimensions of the Sufi premaakhyaans.> >> >As for a local theory of allegory, I have one suggestion. > >It was a few years ago, but I remember that in "Sivaraama's> >commentary on the Naagaananda (edited by T. Ganapati Sastri,> >Trivandrum Sanskrit Series no. 59), he consistently referred> >to the second, 'allegorical' dimension to the plot under the> >rubric of 'garbhokti'. > >> >I don't recall how systematic "Sivaraama was in applying> >this, nor incidentally do I know any details of his time or> >place (though I presume he may have been from Kerala, given> >that he also commented on the plays of Kula"sekharavarman,> >which were I believe works of strictly local circulation). > >I've never seen this rubric used in any work on dramaturgy> >or ala.mkaara---though other list members certainly may have-> >--but at least it might be a place to start.> >> >best,> >> >Whitney> >> >> >---- Original message ----> >>Date: Tue, 1 May 2007 05:58:31 -0500> >>From: mkapstei at UCHICAGO.EDU > >>Subject: pratiika/allegory > >>To: INDOLOGY at liverpool.ac.uk> >>> >>In current Indian writing on Sanskrit drama,> >>the term pratiika-naa.taka is sometimes used for> >>allegorical dramas in the tradition of the> >>Prabodhacandrodaya of K.r.s.namizra, e.g.,> >>Suuryasa.mkalpodaya, Caitanyacandrodaya, Am.rtodaya,> >>etc. But just when and where is this term> >>pratiika-naa.taka first used? Is it, in fact,> >>a modern coinage based on Eng. "allegorical drama"?> >>> >>Even if the term is of recent origin, was there ever> >>another way of theorizing "allegory" in traditional> >>dramaturgy and poetics? (In esoteric religious materials,> >>of course, we find such notions as niguu.dhaartha applied> >to> >>allegorical readings of tantric texts and the like, but> >>I am not interested in that sort of thing here, unless> >>a direct link to notions of literary allegory seems likely.)> >>> >>Of course, as has been widely noted, the practice of> >>allegorical writing in India can be found as early as> >>some hymns of the .rg-veda. However, I am not interested> >here> >>in texts that, as a matter of fact, are allegorical or> >>have been treated as allegorical (e.g., Za.nkara's reading> >of> >>Arjuna's grief at the opening of BhG). My question concerns> >>just the conceptualization and theorization of "allegory."> >>> >>With thanks for your houghts about this.> >>> >>Matthew T. Kapstein> >>Numata Visiting Professor of Buddhist Studies> >>The University of Chicago Divinity School> >>> >>Directeur d'études> >>Ecole Pratique des Hautes Etudes, Paris


More information about the INDOLOGY mailing list